We did NOT Need a Whole New Liturgy.
The Consecration, with Untouched Roman Canon, in Latin, and the Offertory and Consecration offered by The Priest, who is “Alter Christus”and NOT “President of The Assembly.”
As Grand Knight of Monsignor Sherman Council Knights of Columbus #5103, from 1996 until 1998, I was a “President of The Assembly.” However, in this Secular Terminology, I did NOT have the Sacred Authority to Offer The Holy Sacrifice of The Mass.
I have a copy of The 1965 Update of the Tridentine Latin Mass, now utilizing English for a Substantial Part of The Mass. But, with the Exception of The Elimination of The Last Gospel, it is the Mass which in Theology is a True Sacrifice.
The Content of The Mass never changed. The Consecration never had a Separate “Mysterium Fidei” Prayer. For “Mysterium Fidei” was part of the Consecration Prayer in the Roman Canon, when the Wine is changed into The Blood of Christ.
This could have stayed this way with only the High Mass in Latin.
For the Divine Liturgy of St John Chrysostom and Divine Liturgy of St Basil The Great, are Ancient Catholic Liturgies, offered in several languages, but still maintain the Sacrificial Character.
But, a certain Modernist Archabbot of The Benedictine Order, Rembert Weakland, wanted to mix the Mass with Worldly Music, hence the Mess we are in, today. This style of Music went all over the world. Add a new “Translation” of “Pro Multis” into “For All”(Pro Omni), & one knew that something was up.
1967 was a year of the start of Bad Liturgical Muzak and the start of Bad Translation of The Mass. It was a sign of things to come. And 1970 & a Fabricated Liturgy was only 3 years away.